Pizza takeaways

Garage Pizza

4.7 220 reviews 1282 York Rd, Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON L0S 1P0, Canada

Discover this place

Garage Pizza, a delightful pizza takeaway located in Niagara-on-the-Lake, has rapidly garnered a loyal following for its genuine approach to pizzas. Nestled at 1282 York Rd, this hidden gem serves a tantalizing array of red and white cheese pizzas, crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Reviews consistently highlight the exceptional crust—crispy yet chewy, striking the perfect balance between thickness and texture. Patrons like Tanim Ahmed rave about the care and passion evident in every pie, while others, such as Matthew Lalonde, assert that Garage Pizza beats even their homemade creations. Unique offerings such as the Hawaiian and the Meat Lovers reflect a diverse menu that caters to various taste preferences, ensuring something for everyone. Beyond the food, the warm-hearted atmosphere created by the friendly staff enhances the dining experience. Debdatta Rudra’s account of the speedy service and the inviting environment illustrates why take-out from Garage Pizza is so popular. The baked wings also receive glowing reviews, rounding out a delicious menu that keeps diners returning for more. Overall, Garage Pizza is not just about satisfying hunger—it's an experience filled with flavor, community, and warmth that should not be missed.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

College students
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Garage Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Garage Pizza

4.7

220 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 220 reviews

Garage Pizza in Niagara-on-the-Lake is widely praised for its high-quality, freshly made pizzas featuring flavorful toppings and a well-balanced crust that is both chewy and crispy. Customers appreciate the careful craftsmanship and authentic Italian-inspired style, often highlighting the thin crust and generous toppings. The friendly and welcoming atmosphere, despite the unique "garage" setting, adds to the positive dining experience. Many reviews commend the speedy service and the use of fresh ingredients, making it a popular choice for both locals and visitors. While the unconventional setting limits in-house amenities, the overall quality and taste consistently receive strong approval, establishing Garage Pizza as a noteworthy local find for takeout and casual dining.

Tanim Ahmed

Jun 04, 2025

I was driving randomly at Niagara-On-The-lake and found this hidden gem. I have never seen anyone who can make pizza with this amount of care and love. My wife was telling me that it was worth coming here from Toronto just for this pizza. The people in the neighbourhood are awesome and They're warm-hearted, too.Thank you guys. Defeinitely see you again.

Matthew Lalonde

May 13, 2025

I almost never order pizza because it's usually very mid, and pizza made at home with my pizza steel and a good 24 hour dough is just about always better. But garage pizza is the only place I know around niagara that absolutely crushes my homemade pies! Absolutely recommended checking it out

Mickey Cruise

May 12, 2025

Nice little pizza joint. This is a very surprising discovery for me and family. Garage pizza is a must try. My kids loved the pizza and chicken wings we ordered. Nice flavours. Quality ingredients and freshly made pizza. The crust is amazing, not too thick, not too thin, chewy yet crunchy. We ordered a big rectangle sized pizza and we had a lot of left overs, popped it in the oven the next day and still taste amazing. We’ll be back for sure

Debdatta Rudra

Apr 20, 2025

Me and my husband was there for dinner yesterday, it was an awesome experience! We got original Italian style pizzas with thin crust and a plenty of toppings. Meat, cheese and veggies were fresh and our pizzas were made in front of us! They just took 15-20 mints to deliver 3 pizzas with 8 slices each, that was great! The owner and workers were so fun and friendly.. We recommend to try their Hawaiian pizza with pineapple and Guzzler. And It's better to do a take-away.

Charles Grantham

Mar 27, 2025

This is literally a pizza place in a Garage...but other folks are right it’s really good. Great flavors and a crust that is crispy and stays crispy...style wise its kind of in between a NY style pie and a bar pie. no bathrooms but then again it’s literally in a garage so not the end of the world.

Lac-Hong Phi

Mar 26, 2025

First timer from London. What a great find. Friendly people and the pizza smelled INCREDIBLE!!! Sadly I had to perform at a wedding nearby and didn't get to eat pizza till it had gotten cold.. But my family had some the following day and still raved about it!!! Milli grazie, Franca. Alla prossima! ...

Brendan Green

Mar 17, 2025

Seriously the very best pizza I have ever had! Everything was so fresh and the pizza was cooked to perfection! Not sloppy or sauggy, my Italian wife approved this 100% we can’t order from anywhere else! Thanks Franca for the delicious pizza!

DAVE LAUS

Mar 03, 2025

We ordered once again and I can't say enough about how good the food is, the service and quality. The ingredients are fresh, and most importantly real. The crust and dough is perfect. We ordered the potato pizza and it was incredible. This place should be on a "You should eat here" . FOOD network, you hear me? The staff here are very friendly and kind and care about their business.